Serving the Youngstown, OH Area

Custom Frosted Sugar Cookies that Make Any Event Special

Looking for a way to sweeten up your next event? Whether you're celebrating a birthday, anniversary, or any other special occasion, decorative sugar cookies are the perfect gift! Click the button below and let me create a beautiful set of cookies just for you!

Start Your Order

Hi, I'm Danielle!
I create custom-made, decorative sugar cookies to help you wow your guests and turn any gathering into a special event. I spent my childhood baking holiday treats to give away to friends and family and now I want to bake for you! To start brainingstorming your next cookie creation, contact me today!

Need a Custom Design?

Here's how it works...

We plan your cookies
We share ideas and pictures over texts and emails so I make sure you get exactly what you want.

I bake and decorate
I get to work in the Heritage Baking kitchen, bringing your cookie creations to life!

Your cookies are ready!
Bagged and ready, your cookies are picked up or delivered directly to you.

Start a Custom Design Order

"Heritage Baking Co has the best cookies! Danielle has mastered the art of the cute cookie that actually tastes as good as it looks. Perfect for special events, holidays, or just as a pick-me-up. Plus, I love supporting a Youngstown small business!"

- Carrie Drummond

"Heritage Baking Co. has the hands down the best custom cookies in the game. Danielle’s talent is exceptional in that every little detail is consistently perfect. I always hate to eat them because they look too beautiful to eat. However, not only are they beautiful, but they also taste amazing. Danielle has made custom cookies for most of my biggest life events. From a Parks & Rec themed bachelorette to my October wedding, she captured every vision wonderfully. No matter the event or occasion, Danielle always executes on the theme with her cookies beyond expectations. 10/10 would absolutely recommend."
- Becca Ghasab

"Danielle’s cookies are absolutely incredible. She completed a large order of Christmas cookies for me for my coworkers last year, and they were a huge hit! She also made my bridal shower cookies, and the guests couldn’t stop talking about them. Sometimes it’s hard to find cookies that look good AND taste good, but hers check all of the boxes. I’m always so impressed! I highly recommend Danielle & Heritage Baking!"

- Lauren House

6632 Shawbutte Street, Poland, OH 44514